Data Centers Threaten 15 Years of Climate Gains

A new report, released today by the Sierra Club, reveals how data center projects are on track to reverse 15 years of climate emissions reductions over the next three years and increase local air pollution for nearby communities. The report, Artificial Intelligence, Real Pollution, provides a framework for New Jersey to reduce toxic emissions for communities and the financial impacts on families and small businesses. Voters rejected the high prices they are paying for data centers earlier this month, and the Sierra Club report offers solutions in the form of strict policies on data centers.

By 2030, the U.S. could emit 2.3 billion tons of carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions from the electric sector alone, an increase driven by data centers that rely on fossil fuels. This higher level of climate pollution would rival emissions from the U.S. electric sector in 2011, potentially undoing years of progress and leading to catastrophic interference in the climate. 

Driving increased emissions are nearly 250 gigawatts of new gas-burning power plants that are planned or under construction to power data centers. That is enough to power nearly 75 percent of all U.S. households. 

In addition, the Sierra Club’s new report shows that gas plants built on-site at the largest data centers will be significant contributors to increased pollution. The twelve largest data centers with on-site gas plants could emit nearly 180 million tons of CO2, equivalent to the entire electric sectors of Florida and Pennsylvania. The gas plants are also expected to be large sources of health-harming pollutants, including fine particulates, oxides of nitrogen, and hazardous chemicals.

Particularly in New Jersey, we have seen a lack of transparency when it comes to the use of dirty, backup diesel generators. Microsoft’s DataOne was fined $1 million for the illegal operation of 62 diesel generators without the requisite DEP permits in Vineland. While the fine was a good step, DataOne should have been required to cease operations until it fully complied with the law. 

Additionally, a public comment period just closed for the DEP’s Draft Air Permit for the Sentinel – Princeton Nurseries data center in South Brunswick, which proposes at least 12 diesel backup generators. The data center’s diesel particulate matter reaches a near 10-in-a million cancer risk during basic maintenance, mimicking major source pollution levels under a minor source classification (see Sierra Club comments here).

These examples are deeply concerning and speak to the larger pattern of air and climate pollution highlighted in Sierra Club’s new report. 

In response, NJ Sierra Club Energy Policy and Legislative Director, David Eisenhauer, issued the following statement: 

“Unfortunately, New Jersey knows all too well the impacts of unchecked pollution. Because of this, our state has become one of the most stringent in the nation when it comes to regulating it. Now, as power-hungry data centers become their own dirty industry, relying far too heavily on fossil fuels, we will not let history repeat itself. 

Moreover, this report makes clear that addressing the environmental harms of data centers requires national, coordinated action.

New Jersey has taken several steps forward, including enacting the Data Center Fair Share Act, S731 (Burzichelli)/A796 (Bailey) which is highlighted in the report, enacting the Water and Energy Reporting law, S3379 (Ruiz)/A4096 (Venezia), enacting the End Data Center Tax Credits Act, S4390 (Cryan)/A5165 (Macurdy), moving forward legislation to increase public transparency, S4304 (Greenstein)/A2774 (Katz), and working towards a strong siting bill, S4402 (Singleton)/ A5294 (Moen). 

We can do more by pushing for stronger clean energy requirements so that large data centers meet their energy needs from sources such as wind, solar, and geothermal, along with battery storage.

This report confirms what we already know: the cost of inaction in terms of impacts to our health and climate is catastrophic. Now more than ever, it’s critical for our government leaders to protect our communities and environment with strict, decisive regulations on Big Tech and its polluting data center projects. The NJ Sierra Club will continue to fight at the local, state, and federal levels to hold these companies accountable and protect our climate, clean air, clean water, natural resources, our wallets, and our health.” 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *