William E. Cleary Sr. | Cleary’s Notebook News
UPDATED
WHAT A NIGHTMARE
Gloucester City, NJ (August 26, 2026)–More and more I am finding it so difficult to deal with businesses, utility companies and those in the medical field online. The wait time to talk with someone can be an
hour or more. In some cases you can’t talk to anyone. Instead you are switched to a chat-line that seems to lead nowhere. The frustration of navigating these systems is overwhelming. Most recently, we wanted to change our cellphone provider. What an ordeal this has become. After countless hours, we still haven’t been able to get that dilemma solved.
We had been with Verizon forever, and although the service was reliable, the cost for our mobile phone plan had become exorbitant. Tired of paying such high bills, we decided to switch to Consumer Cellular based on some recommendations. Unfortunately, the phone reception was abysmal, making it difficult to use the service effectively. Our next choice, based on further research and consumer feedback, was T-Mobile.
BAD MOVE
On June 7, 2026, I spent over an hour applying for a T-Mobile senior citizen 55 and over mobile account for my wife and me. The following day, I printed out the seven-page contract that I signed electronically. As I reviewed it, I was shocked to discover that I was billed $639 for an iPhone 17e that T-Mobile had advertised as being free as part of their promotion for new customers. Katherine the T-Mobile rep that I chatted with the day before emphasize several time that phone was free; “On us,” she wrote.
On June 8, 2026, I called the T-Mobile Consumer phone number 1-844-962-2361 in an effort to resolve the discrepancy regarding the charges. What followed was a labyrinth of frustration: I was transferred to five different representatives over the course of the next three hours. Each and every time, I had to explain my situation from the very beginning. It felt like I was stuck in a maddening loop. The last representative I spoke with told me that I would have to fill out a new contract since there was no record of the one I had submitted just the day before. I was adamant that I had a copy of the contract and could easily send proof, but they insisted that this was not necessary. This only escalated my frustration as I felt I was being dismissed.
In an effort to escalate the issue, I decided to send an email to Srini Gopalan, the T-Mobile President and Chief Executive Officer, elaborating on my predicament and hoping he would intervene. Unfortunately, my hopes for a resolution were dashed when I received no response from him. I felt completely powerless and unheard in a system that seemed to prioritize bureaucracy over genuine customer service. The experience has left me feeling disillusioned with T-Mobile and questioning the reliability of its service. Each step of this journey has underscored the challenges consumers face when dealing with large corporations in today’s digital age, where human connection feels increasingly lost.
COPY YOUR CHAT CONVERSATION
From previous conversations we have had online with sales people I learned that you should copy your chat with them for future reference. Even if the salesperson tells you that they will send you a copy of your discussion it is best that you don’t rely on that promise. Fortunately I followed my own advice and was able to retrieve my JUNE dialogue with the T-Mobile representative named Katherine. We asked about their free phone offer. To our suprised we learned that T-Mobile stores may not have the same offer as their website. And we learned that those free phone offers required the customer to buy a more expensive package. Katherine confirmed that the free phone promotion was available but…”Yes! we have that promotion available but it is attach to a different plan that includes unlimited data talk and text and Netflix standard on us this plan has a cost of $140+tax with autopay.”
I researched different plans offered by this cellphone company, and one of them was a 55 and over plan. I had also corresponded via email for the amount we would receive for our trade-in which was $500. As we “Chatted” back and forth she kept trying to sell me the more expensive plan.
Katherine said, “My recommendation to have a new phone will be take the offer for the iPhone 16 because the iPhone 15 and the 16 starts allow 5G connection and you can enjoy this version of phone this promotion give you $315 off in a new iPhone 16. So will cost you just for $414.99 this will be divided in the next 24 months so will be just 17.29 per month.
When I mention that T-Mobile had offered to buy my old iPhone for $500 she was surprised. “Thank you so much for letting me know! With that offer that they will give you for the trade we can add a promotion that allow us to give you a iPhone 17e on us also give you $630 off for a iPhone 16.”
I accepted the offer which I felt would include the free phone based on my conversation with Katherine. However, when I printed out the contract it included on the back of one page that I was charged $639.
“For both lines with the Essentials choice Plan the monthly cost will be $60+tax with autopay, and the iPhone 17e will not have a monthly cost because it is on us. “
“You just need to pay the taxes on the device that is a one time charge.“
Speed forward to August. We were billed $153.00 for not paying our bill on time and to re-activate our phone lines. We never received a notice when our bill was due. After paying that amount I canceled my phone. Since my wife’s phone was for free it required her to remain with T-Mobile for two years. Thinking it would be easier to speak with someone in person a trip to the T-Mobile store in Brooklawn was made.
ANOTHER BAD MOVE!
The person we spoke with was condescending and kept interrupting me when I tried to ask questions. It was incredibly frustrating to engage in a discussion where I felt my concerns were not being heard. Each time I attempted to clarify my points or seek further information, he would cut me off, making it difficult for me to convey the full scope of my situation. When I tried to explain my June 7, 2026 agreement made with Katherine, he persistently interrupted me, which only heightened my frustration.
I had taken the June agreement with me as evidence of my claims. When I showed it to him, he immediately focused on the date at the top of the page, which was August 15. With what seemed like dismissive confidence, he stated, “You made this contract just recently,” pointing to the date. I tried to explain that the date reflected when I printed a copy of the June 7 contract that he was currently reading. It was a critical moment that showcased the importance of clear communication, yet he seemed unwilling to understand my explanation.
Moreover, when the conversation shifted to the matter of the charges for the free phone, he insisted that it was because I had canceled my account. However, I made sure to clarify, “I didn’t cancel my account until I received the $153 invoice.” This timeline was crucial, but it felt as though my words were falling on deaf ears.
After our interaction, I left there wondering what to do next.
The situation left me feeling confused and powerless, as I am the principal on the contract, and since I canceled my agreement, I can no longer access our account. The phone recording that guides users on how to change their PIN number states that in order to make that change, you need to use the app on your telephone by navigating to the security category. However, the response I received was that it wasn’t working, and I was advised to log into their website instead.
This entire experience has been quite disheartening, as it appears that customer service representatives are often not equipped to handle the unique nuances of individual agreements or recognize the importance of honoring previous commitments. Moving forward, I will need to find a way to address these concerns effectively, ensuring that I retain access to my account and resolve the issues related to the unexpected charges. As it is today, I don’t know how much I need to pay for Connie’s monthly fee. It wouldn’t surprise me to learn that her telephone service has been discontinued.
I went back to Verizon. Their 55 and over package is also $30, plus they offer a $10 discount if you are a veteran. And, if you have Verizon Fios there are further discounts.
Below Letter to T-Mobile’s Top Dog
Below is the full Chat conversation with T-Mobile Rep.
I read that you are avertizing Get the new iphone 17 e on us no trade in needed
Katherine
said:
Yes!, all the fee will be the activation fee that is $10 per line.
You said:
What is that offer about?
Katherine
said:
Yes! we have that promotion available but is attach to a different plan that is our experience more plan that includes unlimited data talk and text and Netflix standard on us this plan has a cost of $140+tax with autopay.
You said:
How can we get Connie a new phone? It has to be an Apple product. Ill keep my iphone pro15
You said:
First, have you heard anything about 4G being done away with?
You said:
Consumer Cellular said the reason Connie can’t reach me at all times when she is out is because the government is doing away with 4G towers?
Katherine
said:
Yes, right now all the reds are in 5G coverage, that is why all our plan have include this type of signal with no additional costs.
Also my recommendation to have a new phone will be take the offer for the iPhone 16 because the iPhone 15 and the 16 starts allow 5G connection and you can enjoy this version of phone this promotion give you $315 off in a new iPhone 16. so will cost you just for $414.99 this will be divided in the next 24 months so will be just 17.29 per month.
You said:
So, what can you do to get her a updated phone?
Katherine
said:
What do you think about the option with the promotion for the iPhone 16?
You said:
Earlier after I placed my IME Number I received a notice that it was worth $500 as a trade in?
Katherine
said:
The iPhone 15 or the iPhone 11?
You said:
The 11
Katherine
said:
Thank you so much for let me know! with the off that give you the trade we can add a promotion that allow us to give you a iPhone 17e on us also give you $630 off in a iPhone 16
You would like to make a prequalification to check if we can applied the promotion for the iPhone 17e on us?
You said:
The PRO MAX Model iphone takes unbelieveable photos. I don’t want to give mine up for that reason. If I could have gotten a upgrade that was a pro max I would have said yes. If we give Connie the 16e what would the price be?
Katherine
said:
The iPhone 16e right now is not in stock, but my recommendation will be give her a iPhone 17e or the iPhone 15 that will be on us as well.
You said:
To be clear when you say that will be on us.
You said:what is the final costs for our new Tmobile lines and the iphone 17e
Katherine
said:
For both lines with the Essentials choice Plan the monthly cost will be $60+tax with autopay, and the iPhone 17e will not have a monthly cost because on us. you just need to pay the taxes on the device that is a one time charge.
You said:
Great! Would it be easier if I drive to the nearby Brooklawn TMobile store, it is 2 miles from me.
You said:
Or we can continue online. If it is easier for you.
Katherine
said:
To be honest my recommendation will be making the order online because in the store they do not have the same promotion that we have.
You said:
Okay with me.
Katherine
said:
If you want we can start the order!, can you please help me filling out the following form.
Enter your info securely
The personal info you submit is encrypted and protected.
You said:
Okay
Katherine
said:
Thank you Please let me know when you have finished and if you have any question or issues with the form.
You said:
Please review the info I sent you
Katherine
said:
Thank you so much!
I have the information, let me send you the second form.
Thank you so much! I receive the information, now we need to create a PIN for the order can you please send it in the following form.
You said:
I sent u the last form, i had trouble entering the last 4 numbers of the SS did you receive it?
Katherine
said:
Yes, I receive it no worries.
You said:
what is the final costs for our new Tmobile lines and the iphone 17e
Katherine
said:
For both lines with the Essentials choice Plan the monthly cost will be $60+tax with autopay, and the iPhone 17e will not have a monthly cost because on us. you just need to pay the taxes on the device that is a one time charge.
You said:
Great! Would it be easier if I drive to the nearby Brooklawn TMobile store, it is 2 miles from me.
You said:
Or we can continue online. If it is easier for you.
Katherine
said:
To be honest my recommendation will be making the order online because in the store they do not have the same promotion that we have.
You said:
Okay with me.
Katherine
said:
If you want we can start the order!, can you please help me filling out the following form.
Enter your info securely
The personal info you submit is encrypted and protected.
You said:
Okay
Katherine
said:
Thank you Please let me know when you have finished and if you have any question or issues with the form.
You said:
Please review the info I sent you
Katherine
said:
Thank you so much!
I have the information, let me send you the second form.
Thank you so much! I receive the information, now we need to create a PIN for the order can you please send it in the following form.
You said:
I sent u the last form, i had trouble entering the last 4 numbers of the SS did you receive it?
Katherine
said:
Yes, I receive it no worries.
You said:
I just forwarded my pin
Katherine
said:
Thank you so much! I’ll start the order, let me tell you we have The iPhone 17e in black, pink and white. which color do you prefer?
You said:
pink
Katherine
said:
Great! to add the trade can you please send me the IMEI number for the iPhone 11, in the following form.
Enter your info securely
The personal info you submit is encrypted and protected.
Thank you so much!, i receive the IMEI, can you please let me know the device have any damage?
You said:
It is free of any scratches or screen cracks. Very good condition.
Katherine
said:
Perfect!, Please take in mind that you need to turn off the Find my iPhone feature before send it.
You said:
will do
Katherine
said:
Also I would like to inform you that we have in our 5G Unlimited home internet available in your area, I would like to offer you our Rely plan this have up to 400 mbps for download speed and up to 55mbps for upload speed this plan normally has a price of $50+tax with autopay. but we can ad a discount for have a phone line. so for you will be just $35+tax with autopay. This have a 15 day free trial and today for this you don’t need to pay anything, you would like to add it?
You said:
Thank you. However, I just signed with another carrier for internet service and our cable TV.
You said:
Would you like to take my credit card to settle up what I owe for today?
Katherine
said:
Yes please I’m in that part, so for today the total will be $61.07 can you please fill out the following form with your payment information.
Enter your info securely
The personal info you submit is encrypted and protected.
You said:
I don’t want to use auto pay. I had a bad experience. Despite closing the bank account the bank said it wasn’t closed and they kept charging me late fees. Ill make my payment directly to Tmobile
You said:
Each time I sent the form to you it came back because I didn’t click autopay
Katherine
said:
No worries the Autopay is optional there is not need to be add it, also if you like to add it later you can do it, just to confirm the address on the card is the same as your billing address?
You said:
yes,
Katherine
said:
Thank you so much! I’m processing the order, you need to receive a Email asking for a E-signature can you please confirm if you receive it.
Just to give you and advice the device promotion will show just in the bill, not in the email. because the promotions will show as credits in your bill.
You said:
Okay, thank you for your help. My dinner is ready. Do you need anything else from me?
Katherine
said:
Do you add the E-signature?
You said:
I don’t believe so. Was that on the email?
Katherine
said:
Yes, in the email you need to click on “I agreed” and then will ask you to attach your name or e-signature.
This is the last part to complete the order please let me know when you attach the E-Signature.
You said:
okay
Katherine
said:
Thank you, I’ll be here.
You said:
I am having a problem finding where to sign
Katherine
said:
Let me send you some steps.
Quick & Easy Steps to Sign Your Agreement Here’s all you need to do: 1. Check your inbox for an email from donotreply@notifications.t-mobile.com. 2. Click the “Sign Now” link in that email to get started. 3. Review the terms and conditions, then tap “I Consent”. 4. Scroll down to the financial privacy policy and tap “I Consent” again. 5. Take a moment to read the purchase disclosure agreement. 6. Finally, scroll down and hit “Sign and Agree”—and you’re all set!
Please let me know if you have questions or issues with the service agreement link.
Enter your info securely
The personal info you submit is encrypted and protected.
7:09PM